Diversion and alternatives to incarceration fair and just. This happens commonly in regular traffic court but can be used as a. Understanding diversion programs christopher cosley. Some of the qualities of effective pretrial and diversion programs are the next topic. Diversion programs can help keep youth out of the system. Adolescent diversion project michigan state university. Although diversion programs provide an opportunity to redirect youths away from formal processing in the juvenile justice system while still holding them accountable for their actions, certain limitations should be acknowledged and understood. The programs are often run by a police department, court, a district attorneys office, or outside agency. Diversion programs are cheaper and more effective than. The state attorneys office juvenile diversion programs, also known as youth offender programs, consist of both prevention and intervention strategies. In diversion programs, cases are taken out of the criminal justice system while the defendant participates in treatment, counseling, andor some other type of rehabilitation. Discuss the advantages and disadvantages of prevention and diversion programs describe three major types of prevention list and discuss several specific prevention and diversion programs. Major advantage of diversion programs is avoiding justice system processing.
Treatment, services, and intervention programs for child. Appealingly, in four programs in which a cost evaluation was conducted, cases that were routed to diversion used fewer resources than similar comparison cases rempel et al. Across the country today, there are hundreds of organizations seeking to equip those returning from prison with the skills, character, and practical knowledge necessary to be successful upon reintegration into their community. These programs emphasize counseling, treatment, and behavior modification over punitive measures. Diversion, any of a variety of programs that implement strategies seeking to. Youth courts also called teen, peer, and student courts are diversion programs in which youth are sentenced by their peers for minor crimes, offenses, andor violations. Dec 06, 2017 when it comes to reducing mass incarceration, some solutions are actually staring us right in the face. Prevention and diversion programs sage publications. Find standards for prevention programs, reports from state programs, and information on types of programs addressing the prevention of child abuse and neglect. Young offenders to assess treatment, services, and intervention programs designed for juvenile offenders under the age of. Diversion programs are alternative prosecution programs that are available to many firsttime offenders who have committed nonviolent felonies or misdemeanors and are being prosecuted in cook county. Diversion programs can help keep youth out of the system by preventing arrests emily haneycaron, jdphd candidate, juvenile law center legal intern, april 15, 2016 each year, over 1 million youth are arrested across the country, and 95% of those arrests are for nonviolent offenses.
Yet, it represents an opportunity to identify those who could benefit from substance abuse treatment and begin to engage them in the process. Diversion keeps kids out of the criminal justice system. The brief lists a sampling of programs currently in use across the country. Types of diversion programs currently used 821 words. The criminal justice outcomes of jail diversion programs. These programs are intended to give youth and families every resource available to assist them in becoming a productive citizen. Diversion programs can last from six months to a year or more. Diversion is a term used to describe intervention approaches that redirect.
However, there is also an adult diversion program, which is available to first time. The cons of diversion are that diversion might be a way of promoting deterrence. Adolescent diversion project michigan state university program goals the adolescent diversion project adp is a strengthsbased, universityled program that diverts arrested youth from formal processing in the juvenile justice system and provides them with communitybased services. Annual water use reporting requirements for water right holders. List and discuss several specific prevention and diversion programs. Diversion programs exist at multiple levels within the criminal justice process, and likewise, have variations in their effectiveness for each of the desired outcomes evaluated, as well as in. A summary of diversion programs for drug and drugrelated. Of that total, rand concluded 61 percent meet the criteria currently used by the countys office of diversion and reentry odr to determine whether an individual may be put forward to the courts as a candidate for diversion. Diversion programs are wellsuited to screening for substance use disorders and referring to the appropriate community agency for followup assessment and treatment. Determine the specific type of diversion program you wish to implement. Currently, the federallyfunded substance abuse mental health services administration samhsa technical assistance and policy analysis center for jail diversion tapa lists 294. Diversion, particularly of juveniles, is designed to avoid negative labels that accompany formal case processing.
Jlarc to study the community diversion incentive program operated by the virginia department of corrections. What are the key characteristics of the diversion programs. Identify red flags for prescription drug diversion identify current prescription drug diversion trends define the role of the pharmacist in terms of corresponding responsibility for prescription drug diversion recognize deceptive prescribing patterns used to hide prescription drug abuse and diversion pharmacy technician. In 1992, a national survey of jail diversion programs estimated that only about 52 jails in the u. Precharge diversion is generally used with lowerrisk youths following their contact with the police. These programs are designed to help firsttime offenders avoid criminal convictions and jail time by participating and completing diversion. This research examines two police precharge diversion programs in ontario, canada. Why reentry programs are important charles koch institute. Diversion programs in americas criminal justice system. Defendants typically pay for their diversion programs with a fee to the court, treatment center, or both.
Pretrial diversion ptd is an alternative to prosecution which seeks to divert certain offenders from traditional criminal justice processing into a program of supervision and services administered by the u. Types of juvenile rehabilitation programs how to adult. Because diversion programs can vary in terms of points of contact, setting, target population, and form of intervention or services delivered, you will also need to look at the specific research and information available on the particular type of diversion program that could be implemented in your jurisdiction. The program also seeks to influence decision makers to streamline funding to those programs proven to be effective in addressing the root causes of crime.
Different pros and cons characterize diversion some. Program name california state water quality control board. The type of juvenile rehabilitation programs used depends on the resources in the. This project identified 51 programs operating for the diversion of drug and drugrelated offenders throughout australia.
Some advantages of diversion are the ease of caseloads on the court systems. Prevention and intervention programs for juvenile offenders vol. Section 7173 of the criminal code of canada clearly states. That is certainly the case when it comes to diversion programs in the state of kansas. When it comes to reducing mass incarceration, some solutions are actually staring us right in the face. Postbooking diversion programs these are the most prevalent type of pretrial diversion program cowell, broner, and dupont, 2004. This research is an attempt to understand the popularity of diversion over time and explore the purposes, beyond that of a reduction in the use of youth court, that diversion serves. Informal diversion occurs when an official in the justice system decides, by using the. Adult offender diversion programs public safety canada. Diversion programs are a deferment of the criminal process, where offenders can participate in communitybased treatment programs. These programs emphasize counseling, treatment, and.
Please note, however, that this iguide does not focus on law enforcement and schoolbased diversion programs that aim to minimize youth arrests and referrals, as there is currently not a lot of research on these specific types of diversion programs. A person charged with a crime fulfills certain requirements, such as completing. If you divert and use water from a surface water source such as a lake, creek, stream, or river, or you divert water from a subterranean stream that flows in a known and definite channel, california law requires you to report your diversion and use to the state water board, division of water rights. The juvenile and adult diversion program is designed to hold juveniles and adults accountable for their behavior and to recognize and repair the harm they have done to their victims and the community.
Diversion programs are suspensions of the criminal process. Said report described the findings of the first longitudinal study of diversion cases in south africa that surveyed 460 former programme participants. Describe the types of diversion programs currently used. A juvenile diversion program has the ability to be used as an intervention strategy for first time offenders who have broken the law and found themselves in the. Several states have passed laws that authorize and appropriate funds for juvenile diversion programs, but other states have failed to support the continuation of diversion programs once the federal funding ended. The final section examines a subset of the literature covering the best practices and challenges involved in evaluating juvenile diversion programs. Please email your instructor answering the following questions.
Diversion is tailored for persons accused of crimes for whom voluntary mental health treatment and support services are a reasonable alternative to criminal justice sanctions. Diversion, any of a variety of programs that implement strategies seeking to avoid the formal processing of an offender by the criminal justice system. Is what i tell the diversion worker admissible against me at trial later on. About 110 youth are now referred to the program each month, of which about 75 are referred on to community services. The community diversion incentive col program was created by the legislature in 1980 to provide the judicial system with an. This fjp compendium offers guiding principles for implementing alternatives to incarceration and developing diversion programs. Diversion programs and firstoffender programs nolo. At a time of limited budgets, it is imperative that we consider the cost effec.
For the current study, participants were nonviolent offenders aged 11 to 18 who entered the juvenile justice system between june 2010 and december 31, 20. Schwalbe and colleagues 2012 examined the results from 28 studies of juvenile diversion programs and found there was no significant effect on recidivism or0. Some of these individuals are good candidates for diversion in the approximately 50 jailbased diversion programs that currently exist. On completion of this chapter, students should be able to do the following. The effectiveness of criminal justice diversion initiatives.
Diversion and alternatives to incarceration fair and. Several programs have emerged in recent years to divert individuals with serious mental illness and cooccurring substance use disorders from jail to communitybased treatment and support services. An additional 7 percent are also potentially eligible for diversion, while 32 percent are not, according to the study. Arrestees with cooccurring disorders can enter a diversion program in either the pre or postbooking phase. However, some diversion programs may target highrisk juvenile offenders, or youths. The youth intervention and diversion program is now one of the major components of j divisions crime reduction strategy. Several types of diversion, including drug treatment courts, are discussed. To date, 871 youth have been screened using the validated screening tool. A diversion program in the criminal justice system is a form of sentence in which the criminal offender joins a rehabilitation program, which will help remedy the behavior leading to the original arrest, allow the offender to avoid conviction and, in some jurisdictions, hide a criminal record. Diversion does not necessarily require a child to be placed in a formal programme but includes interventions such as receiving a police caution, writing an. The most common types of diversion programs are drug courts, but some states also have mental health courts and programs for people charged with relatively minor domestic. Like prebooking diversion programs, postbooking programs also are aimed at diverting offenders with mental illness or cooccurring disorders from the criminal justice system lattimore et al. Acknowledge the criticism surrounding certain types of diversion programs. However, when available, research related to these types of programs has been included.
Currently, there are many types of formal mentoring programs generally. What can we say about the effectiveness of jail diversion. With betterresourced programs, we can meaningfully address racial disparities in juvenile justice, take steps toward juvenile decarceration, and prevent young people. Statewide evaluation of juvenile diversion programming. The criminal justice outcomes of jail diversion programs for. Prevention programs child welfare information gateway. Diversion also emphasizes positive and constructive character on an offender. Although diversion can come in many forms, the basic principle is wellestablished and straightforward. It includes information on justicerelated programs and assigns evidence ratingseffective, promising, and no effectsto indicate whether there is evidence from research that a program achieves its goals. Diversion refers to diverting an accused child away from formal court procedures and towards a more constructive and positive solution. These programs may fall under the authority of governmental or nonprofit agencies. Diversion is based on the principles of restorative justice, which requires that offenders accept responsibility for the crime committed, make amends for their misdeeds and initiating a healing process for themselves, their families, the victims and the community. Types of diversion programs currently used 821 words bartleby. The types of reentry programs that currently exist are almost as varied as the individuals utilizing their services.
Diversion decisions and activities usually occur at the earliest stages of involvement in the juvenile justice system. Juvenile diversion programs state attorney office for. In general, it takes about 16 weeks to complete both rfl and the community service component of the control treatment. When creating a diversionary program, legislators identify the types of offenses that make offenders eligible for it. Typically, diversion programs are used with juvenile first time offenders. This report responds to that mandate and offers recommendations for legislative and execu tive consideration. Criminal justice diversion for persons with mental disorders.
Criminal court programs and services the area of criminal court programs and services include those probationbased functions, programs, and services that operate within the jurisdiction of a court that handles criminal acts that have been committed by a person who is 16 years of age or older. Although those strategies, referred to collectively as diversion, take many forms, a typical diversion program results in a person who has been. Pretrial diversion programs office of justice programs. Diversion, any of a variety of programs that implement strategies seeking to avoid the formal processing. Fortunately, all of the discussions you have with the diversion office for these purposes is confidential and cannot be used against you in court later on.
Diversion programs are initiatives in which persons with serious mental illness who are involved with the criminal justice system are redirected from traditional criminal justice pathways to the mental health and substance abuse treatment systems. Diversion programs are alternatives to initial or continued formal processing of youth in the juvenile delinquency system. The current issue being faced by diversion programs is whether they will survive the federal and state budget cuts. What programs are currently utilised for the diversion of illicit drug users and drugrelated offenders. The community diversion incentive program ofthe virginia. Publications national criminal justice reference service. In october 1998 a nicro report entitled the effectiveness of diversion programmes a longitudinal evaluation of cases was published by the orga nisation.
Diversion keeps kids out of the criminal justice system, but too many police in new jersey fail to use it. One of the major issues surrounding evaluations of diversion programs is the possibility of netwidening. Prevention and intervention programs for juvenile offenders. The objective of this study was to conduct a systematic search of the literature for studies that assess the effectiveness of postbooking and postincarceration diversion programs in north america. Diversion strategies, programs and principles a national scan. We found that doj has used two types of pretrial diversion as alternatives to incarcerationtitle 9 pretrial diversions, which are at the discretion of the u. For more information on diversion programs, refer to tip 21, combining alcohol and other drug abuse treatment with diversion for juveniles in the justice system csat, 1995b. One section of the chapter describes federal initiatives regarding juvenile diversion programs, followed by an overview of the expansion of diversion programs in the 1970s.
1017 534 1205 1286 833 951 883 524 302 842 1105 740 159 1155 964 68 433 567 1196 570 1539 339 348 1410 935 1409 1357 655 1390 167 875 78